The reveal trailer for Persona 5: The Royal sparked much speculation that the re-release might include a playable female protagonist. This possibility has now largely been ruled out, and while the excitement for it was understandable, developers must truly reckon with the inconsistencies that permeate their games’ politics to do both women and queer characters justice.
In Japan, there is currently a movement, known as #KuToo, where women are pushing back against the expectation that they have to wear high heels to work. In a statement to Time, the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare said “In order to make sure that men and women enjoy equal opportunities and treatment, the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare strives to enforce the Equal Employment Opportunity Law and works to create a working environment where all people, including women, can work comfortably.” Basically, whether or not women have to wear heels in the workplace is left to the companies to determine, and it’s a common enough practice that a petition to end it, created by Yumi Ishikawa, now has over 17,000 signatures as of the time of writing.
Women being forced to wear clothing that makes them uncomfortable, sound familiar? Reading about this movement, I was immediately reminded of Persona 5’s Ann, and her iconic catsuit. Much like the women participating in #KuToo, Ann is forced to wear clothing that makes her deeply uncomfortable and is largely ignored when she vocalizes that discomfort. Just as Ishikawa has not yet heard back from any private businesses or the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare, Ann’s complaints are shown on screen, but never addressed.
Ann’s case becomes even more troubling when you consider the intense sexual harassment she’s been dealing with at the hands of the school volleyball coach, Suguru Kamoshida. Despite all the trauma that results from Kamoshida’s behavior, the Persona devs still felt it was appropriate to put her in a revealing suit that even she takes issue with when it first appears on her. Which is strange given how aggressive the critique of Kamoshida is in the game.
Ann’s character, though actually complex and interesting, is ultimately wasted by the game continuously forcing her into the box of “hot, ditzy model” because of the way she embodies her femininity. Futaba, Makoto, and Haru all avoid this because the tropes they embody are meant to be taken more seriously. But Ann’s status as a hot, blonde model constantly pushes her into the role of thirst object, even when this is in direct opposition to the trauma she’s faced. No matter how much she manages to grow, the game always is always policing her, pushing her back into the sexy trope she fought so hard to escape from because of how she presents to the world. This isn’t the only time the Persona franchise has gone down questionable routes with gender.
In Persona 4, Kanji and Naoto both are originally presented as queer, before their arcs ultimately end in them realizing they’re actually straight and cisgendered respectively. Some have argued that this is actually an act of criticism against the strict gender norms found in Japanese society.
In an article on Giant Bomb, user mattbodega said “The key to understanding Kanji isn’t sexuality. It’s Gender.” They go on to talk about how Kanji’s interests in feminine-coded, and because of this the citizens of Inaba perceive him as being gay, whether or not he actually is.
In theory, you could apply this notion to Naoto’s character as well. According to her arc, the only reason she wanted to be a man was that she desperately wanted to be a detective, but because of the strict gender roles in Japanese society, she couldn’t as a woman.
We again see femininity being policed by Japanese society, and there is an argument for Persona 4’s critique of them. But considering Atlus’ past with queer and trans characters (*cough* Catherine *cough*), and extremely poor handling of future ones, I can’t comfortably give it to them. It was bad enough for this game to have two seemingly queer characters be taken away, but having the only queer characters in its sequel be portrayed as basically every harmful stereotype about queer men known to man inspires little to no faith in any critique P Studio may have been making about gender roles or queerness.
The inconsistencies of the series’ politics continue in other areas of Persona 5 as well. The whole game centers on taking out corrupt adults in positions of power, and ultimately focus on taking down a manipulative and cruel politician who wants to keep things the same forever. Yet the politics of these games consistently trend towards the politics of Japan’s own corrupt prime minister and his cronies.
Japan’s Prime Minister, Shinzo Abe, much like the in-game character Masayoshi Shido, has multiple scandals under his belt, one of which caused almost 50% of Japanese voters to feel he should be removed from office in order to take responsibility for it. The similarities don’t end there, however. Both men, real and fictional, embrace ultra-nationalistic policies, seemingly without a care for how it will impact their constituents, or anyone else for that matter.
Much like in American politics, to try to separate these issues from the greater whole is to ultimately weaken and undermine your position.
Shido is the villain of Persona 5, the whole work meant to be a critique of this kind of politician and the apathy that allows men like him to gain and hold power. Considering that Abe is the longest running Prime Minister since World War II, this, on its face, seems like it would be a damning piece of cultural criticism. But it rings hollow as the game actively embraces tropes and beliefs about LGBTQ+ folks and women that members of Abe’s party have claimed publicly multiple times.
So long as the Persona series embraces trans/homophobia, and sexism/victim blaming, it will never be able to truly critique the systems it clearly wants to. These elements are just as much a part of that party and government system as the corruption and ultra-nationalism are. Much like in American politics, to try to separate these issues from the greater whole is to ultimately weaken and undermine your position.
Until P Studio can come to grips with these conflicting viewpoints, I just can’t see them doing a playable woman justice. We don’t need any more instances of oversexualizing young girls who’ve already been traumatized by sexual assault, or portrayals of gay men as aggressive predators on the prowl for high school-aged boys to take against their wills.
There’s often an argument that these beliefs are inherent to Japanese society, but that’s simply not the case. The LDP’s (Abe’s political party) hold over the country for so long is what has been shaping Japan this way, not some inherent queerphobia or sexism. Many schools are introducing unisex uniforms or flexible uniform codes in support of LGBTQ+ students, Tokyo Pride grows larger every year, and there’s an activist group suing the government to allow gay marriage in Japan (something that’s only illegal on a technicality interpreted in the constitution by the government). Japanese society is shifting, despite the conservatism of their government, and P Studio and Atlus need to do the same.
Luckily, there seems to be some hope in this arena. On March 30th, 2019, Job Rainbow, a Japanese organization that brings together LGBT+ and LGBT-friendly businesses for job fairs for queer folks, had one such fair. One of the several companies in attendance was Sega Japan. While this isn’t concrete evidence of change for Atlus or P Studio, it’s hopefully a start.
51 replies on “Persona Can’t Do Women Justice Without Fixing its Conservatism”
Loved this article. I love the Persona games, but, you’re right. There is a long way to go.
Thanks for the article. It was a good read for someone who has never played but is curious about the persona games.
[…] (even if it was doing its damndest to alienate people with its treatment of gay men, abuse victims, women) RPG. This includes additions like new locations, a new party member in gymnast Kasumi Yoshizawa, […]
[…] came out. It was one that, despite some glaring problems in how it treated some of these injustices after they had their spotlight in the plot, helped radicalize me into the man I am today. If Trump being in the White House […]
[…] a matter of time until more entries appear on PC, even if the series still has a long way to go to address its conservatism. Until then, I’m gonna be spending my time hanging out with my friends in […]
Thank you for writing this. As much as I enjoy the series, I can’t help but be continually disappointed by their treatment of female characters, as well as the LGBTQ+ community. Hopefully the criticisms will reach the devs and writers and they will become more motivated to improve.
[…] as we see in Persona 5. While the game has a litany of problems in its storytelling and politics that tend to undercut it, the game’s overall message is about finding it within you to defy […]
[…] hasn’t been up to date or revised in its new iteration. It’s nonetheless mired in sexist tropes, and its illustration of queer characters stays lacking at greatest, and harmful at worst. It might […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] hasn’t been up to date or revised in its new iteration. It’s nonetheless mired in sexist tropes, and its illustration of queer characters stays missing at very best, and destructive at worst. It […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content has not been updated or modified in the new iteration. It’s still mired in sexism Tropicand its performance eccentric characters are still lack the best, and harmful worst time. It may be […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content has not been updated or revised in its new iteration. it’s still mired in sexist tropesand its representation Weird characters remain Shortage best, and Harmful from bad to worse It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] hasn’t been up to date or revised in its new iteration. It’s nonetheless mired in sexist tropes, and its illustration of queer characters stays lacking at finest, and harmful at worst. It could […]
[…] has not been up to date or revised in its new iteration. It’s nonetheless mired in sexism tropesand its illustration of strange characters stay is missing at greatest, and harmful within the […]
[…] of has not been up to date or revised in its new iteration. It is nonetheless mired in sexism tropesand its illustration of queer the characters keep lacking at finest, and dangerous at worst. It […]
[…] turinys nebuvo atnaujintas ar peržiūrėtas naujoje iteracijoje. Tai vis dar įklimpo į seksistą tropaiir jo atvaizdavimas keista personažai lieka trūksta geriausiu atveju ir kenksmingas blogiausiu […]
[…] content of has not been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropesand his representation of queer remains of characters lacking at best, and harmful worst. It may be […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content has not been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropesand its representation of queer characters remain lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may be […]
[…] sisu pole uues iteratsioonis värskendatud ega muudetud. See on endiselt seksist läbi imbunud troopilineja selle esitus imelik tegelased jäävad puudub parimal juhul ja kahjulikud halvimal juhul. Seda […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] nie została zaktualizowana ani zmieniona w nowej iteracji. Nadal jest pogrążony w seksizmie zawiesiai jego wydajność dziwny postacie pozostają niekompletny najlepiej i szkodliwy w najgorszym […]
[…] hasn’t been up to date or revised in its new iteration. It’s nonetheless mired in sexist tropes, and its illustration of queer characters stays missing at best possible, and destructive at worst. […]
[…] content has not been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexism tropesand its representation queer characters remain is missing at best, and harmful in the worst case. It […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] nebuvo atnaujintas ar peržiūrėtas naujoje iteracijoje. Tai vis dar įstrigo seksistinėje tropikaiir jo atstovavimas keista simboliai lieka dingęs geriausiu atveju ir kenksmingas blogiausiu atveju. […]
[…] sisu pole selle uues iteratsioonis värskendatud ega muudetud. See on ikka veel seksismi takerdunud tropidja selle esitus kummaline tegelased jäävad puudulik parimal juhul ja kahjulikud halvimal juhul. […]
[…] obsah nebyl v nové iteraci aktualizován ani změněn. Pořád je to utápěno v sexismu závěsya jeho výkon zvláštní postavy zůstávají neúplný v nejlepším případě a škodlivý při […]
[…] ei ole päivitetty tai muutettu uudessa iteraatiossaan. Se on edelleen juuttunut seksismiin hihnatja sen suorituskykyä outo hahmot jäävät epätäydellinen parhaimmillaan ja haitallista […]
[…] content has not been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still full of sexism tropesand its representation of strange characters remain missing at best, and harmful to the worst. It […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropesand its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may be […]
[…] yeni yinelemesinde güncellenmedi veya değiştirilmedi. Hala cinsiyetçiliğe bulanmış durumda sapanlarve performansı garip karakterler kalır eksik en iyi ihtimalle ve zararlı en kötü ihtimalle. […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] problemātiskākais saturs nav atjaunināts vai mainīts. Tas joprojām ir iegrimis seksismā stropesun tā veiktspēju dīvaini varoņi paliek nepilnīgs labākajā gadījumā un kaitīgs sliktākajā […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content hasn’t been updated or revised in its new iteration. It’s still mired in sexist tropes, and its representation of queer characters remains lacking at best, and harmful at worst. It may […]
[…] content of has not been updated or revised in the new iteration.it still suffers from sexism metaphorand its representation queer letters remain Missing at most, and harm at the worst case. It may be […]
[…] του επανάληψη. Είναι ακόμα βυθισμένο στο σεξιστικό τροπάριακαι την αναπαράστασή του queer χαρακτήρες παραμένουν […]